The Pros and Cons of Different Types of Hardwood Flooring

Unsure where to start? 

Our Mobile Showrooms

Will Come To You

    By submitting this form, I provide my consent to be contacted via text message. I understand that I can revoke this consent at any time.

    or call us at

    Trying to decide what type of floor you need? The majority of the wood floor is oak. However, you can also find feet in many other woods. Different types of hardwood flooring offer different pros and cons. Understanding them can help you choose the right floor for your home.

    Before picking the type of wood, you must consider the kind of flooring. Traditional hardwood floors are made of solid wood. They are lifetime floors since they can be sanded and refinished multiple times. However, they can be costly. Engineered hardwoods are a composite of several layers of wood. It is hardier and more moisture-resistant than solid hardwood, but you can only sand and retain it once or twice. However, the main benefit of pre finished hardwood flooring, solid or engineered, is that the finishes are very durable and sanding or refinishing is rarely ever needed.

    As mentioned, you can choose finished or unfinished wood. Finished wood has been sanded and stained at the factory. Unfinished hardwood is raw, so stain it to the desired color. Installing finished wood is more accessible and less expensive, but unfinished hardwood gives you much more flexibility.

    Oak is a popular flooring type. It is reasonably priced, durable, and comes in various colors, which can be stained. Oak has a visible grain, which helps hide scratches. Plus, oak comes in red and white bases, which provide more significant opportunities. It is a traditional-looking floor, which does not match modern décor. However, oak can turn yellow over time, especially if exposed to sunshine.

    Maple is another excellent option. It is usually lighter because it is difficult to stain. It is more durable and less likely to yellow. So, it is a perfect option if you do not want a darker floor.

    Hickory is a very affordable and durable wood flooring. It has a noticeable grain pattern, which helps disguise scratches. The hardiness is excellent for durability but can make it difficult to install. Plus, the visual grain pattern lends a rustic look, which is not appealing to everyone.

    Cherry is a softer wood, so it is not great for high-traffic rooms. However, it has a warm orange or red natural hue, which darkens over time. The color provides a warm and inviting glow that many people love.

    If you love dark, rich colors, you might want to go with Walnut. It is a durable option that can withstand wear and tear. However, it is one of the more expensive types of wood and can be more challenging to source.

    Ash is similar to oak and maple, with similar durability and grain. Like maple, ash is lighter. It is more expensive than oak floors. The pronounced grain and light color make it an excellent match for beach or coastal properties.

    Mahogany has a deep reddish brown color, is very durable, and is water resistant. It works well in formal and semi-formal settings. However, it is one of the most expensive types of hardwood flooring.

    SMART Carpet and Flooring
    Excellent
    4.8
    Based on 1041 reviews
    review us on
    Maria C.
    Maria C.
    Jay was absolutely amazing! From start to finish, he was patient, kind, and incredibly helpful throughout the entire process. He genuinely cared about how the final product would look and made sure every detail was perfect. His attention to detail and commitment to customer satisfaction really stood out. I highly recommend Jay for anyone looking for a smooth and stress-free experience. Five stars all the way.
    Shana H.
    Shana H.
    Looked at a few national chain stores before speaking with Smart Carpet and Flooring. They were not pushy and provided the information. Loved the outcome!!! Shout out to Louie our rep. Definitely will use again!
    michael R.
    michael R.
    Fast and easy, Joe was great to work with and installed sooner than expected.
    Marina B.
    Marina B.
    Great experience overall, starting with the contract signing with Ryan Ogorzalek. The company then easily accommodated our multiple rescheduling. The installation crew did a great job. No scratches on our freshly painted wall and only a couple of minor ones on the baseboard. I appreciates the general manager Adam stopping by midday to check how everything was going. Will use Smart Carpet again!
    Brian S.
    Brian S.
    I was very satisfied with Smart Carpet. From the first phone call with my Salesman Jim B. to the final installation everything went smoothly and at a great price. They worked around my schedule making it convenient and easy. I would recommend them highly to anyone.
    renee S.
    renee S.
    We are in West Orange N.J, We just had our stairs done by Smart Carpet and Flooring, It looks great and Louie the sales guy made the whole process super easy and fast. Thanks Smart Carpet!!
    Kathy M.
    Kathy M.
    Process was easy and Otto was the best!
    Mitul P.
    Mitul P.
    I used smart carpets and flooring to change flooring for 2 bedrooms. They are highly professional and know what they are doing.Otto Kerler provided excellent recommendation and in budget estimate for the flooring.They are also very quick to coordinate the installation.Overall I always had positive experience with Smart Carpets and Floorings.
    Thomas E.
    Thomas E.
    First time using smart carpet for new carpeting and vinyl flooring. Both crews came in on time and did a fantastic workInstalling Carpet and vinyl flooring planks.Quality workmanship! Highly recommended. Joe Orlando the salesmanExplained all the details of the job and price, 👍👍
    Amy L.
    Amy L.
    Smart carpet did an amazing job replacing my entire house. Louie is an awesome salesperson who was not pushy but showed us options that would work best for our home. He’s super knowledgeable and professional and made sure our installation was done timely and properly. I would highly recommend!
    Randi Silverman, Productivity C.
    Randi Silverman, Productivity C.
    Otto was very kind and knowledgeable. He showed me the variety of carpets he had available based on the time frame I wanted to have the carpets installed. He even came back to check to make sure I was satisfied with the work. [ not many representatives would do this ]. Thank you very much OttoI would highly recommend him as a rep for Smart Carpet.
    cubidoll Ana C.
    cubidoll Ana C.
    Excellent customer service. Meticulous with his work. I will have the other rooms done as well.
    Jean L.
    Jean L.
    Our experience with Louie and Sam was excellent! Smart Carpet replaced the carpet on 2 vintage staircases in our 1830s house, which was challenging. Louie was meticulous with the measurements, and very patient with helping us make the best choice. Sam was very efficient and careful with the installation, and kept us posted every step of the way. Both were very professional and responsive. Would recommend Smart Carpet without hesitation!Jean L., Somerset County, NJ
    Bill
    Bill
    Loved it Jay Carter was excellent
    Christina K.
    Christina K.
    I have purchased carpet from Smart Carpet several times now and I have never been disappointed. Highly recommend! The salespeople, and I have had a couple over the years are very knowledgeable and no pressure. Give them a try before you purchase elsewhere.
    Michele H.
    Michele H.
    New bathroom floor installed. Onsite visit to select floor was easy and quick. Time secure materials was under 2 weeks. Actual total install time was under 2 hours. Clean and efficient and the floor looks great.
    Elaine L.
    Elaine L.
    Louie was patient, knowledgeable, and wasn’t pushy. He really wanted us to be happy with our choice. Day of installation he came by to see if we were satisfied. Top notch customer service!Sam, the installer, was excellent! He did a beautiful job!
    Robert B.
    Robert B.
    Very quick, efficient and courteous. The crew cleaned up all debris and vacuumed the area. I have used Smart Carpet a few other times in the past and they always met my expectations. The sales rep was very knowledgeable and courteous and was not pushy at all.I am very satisfied.
    Matthew S.
    Matthew S.
    I ordered Shaw carpet through Costco and SMART, and am happy with the carpet and installation. Ruth was the sales person who came out for measurements and to show samples, and she made the process easy for us.
    Lauren & Jason H.
    Lauren & Jason H.
    Adam made the entire process easy and fun! He provided us with guidance and recommendations based on what we wanted and the end result was perfect. I would highly recommend working with Adam and Smart Carpet for all your flooring needs.
    Melanie H.
    Melanie H.
    Smart Carpet was so easy to work with and we absolutely love our new carpet in the basement! It’s everyone’s new favorite room!
    Richard L.
    Richard L.
    Excellent job. Your crew went above and beyond to make the floor installation a success for me. Thanks for a job well done.
    Sharon S.
    Sharon S.
    Smart Carpet did a fantastic job for me I love my new carpet
    Jennifer M.
    Jennifer M.
    My experience with Smart Carpet and Flooring was perfect from beginning to end! Everyone is professional and courteous. The whole process was smooth and fast. I love my new floors and highly recommend Smart Carpet and their staff.
    Joe C.
    Joe C.
    Rug looks great and was installed cleanly
    Patricia
    Patricia
    From sales to final install it was an awesome experience. Matt Connor the salesperson is very kind and professional. He gave me a great deal. Installers James and Juliano did the job quickly and efficiently. I couldn't be happier with my new kitchen floor! I highly recommend SMART CARPET AND FLOORING!!
    Yvonne J.
    Yvonne J.
    Workers were knowledgeable, professional, on time and fast. The carpet looks beautiful
    Janelle M.
    Janelle M.
    The installers were professional and detailed felt comfortable I was impressed they did great job and kept to their word.
    Dianna D.
    Dianna D.
    I can’t say enough good things about the customer service and prices at Smart Carpet and Flooring. In my last home they carpeted my entire home, upstairs and downstairs. Most recently I was looking for an area rug for my family room. I looked in several places and when I found what I liked, I priced it and once again Smart Carpet delivered Adam Forbes has been my sales person. He is outstanding. He went above and beyond for me to be sure I was fully satisfied with product and price. My most recent purchase, the area rug in the photo below, he personally delivered and installed for me. This is clearly a company for whom the customer matters. While I rely on these reviews when making my purchases. I rarely do them myself but here I feel compelled to support Smart Carpet and Flooring. Trust me you won’t be disappointed!
    Frank B.
    Frank B.
    I am a customer from Staten Island NY and Louie helped with the amazing service we received with the demo in my home, the sale, delivery and installation. We are extremely happy with the beautiful product and the expert installation and personal care we received. I would highly recommend to my friends and family.
    Brian S.
    Brian S.
    Adam made the process of picking out our new laminate floors a breeze. He came with dozens of options to fit every budget and was very knowledgeable about the different grades of flooring. He got us exactly what we wanted for a very reasonable price. Within a couple weeks we had a crew out to lay the new floor. The crew was very professional and worked diligently, finishing the job way faster than we thought, without any sacrifice to quality. I highly recommend Smart Carpet and Floors for your next project.
    Steve D.
    Steve D.
    Sales process with Greg was clear and transparent. Installation team were really quick , efficient and delivered a quality product .Will work with Greg again for sure
    Mike O.
    Mike O.
    Carpet looks great. So happy with it. Great to work with and very professional. They did a great job. Will use again
    Phyllis B.
    Phyllis B.
    Joe Orlando explained the process very well. The team arrived on time and accomplished putting down the floor exceptionally well. The men were professional and accommodating to our requests. They took care of the entire job from start to finish. Would highly recommend.
    Sally W.
    Sally W.
    Steve was excellent..spent a lot of time going through the options of both carpet and hardwood. The fitting was perfect and Steve personally checked we were happy. Outstanding.
    Greyson W.
    Greyson W.
    This was my second time using Smart Carpet since purchasing my home in Sayreville in 2018. My sales agent Louie was a pleasure to work with from start to finish. I love the final outcome with my carpet, the color, the price, and overall the customer service, which was top tier! Thank you, Louie! I'll be sure to reach out for the next flooring job! 😊
    J K E
    J K E
    I chose Smart Carpet & Flooring, in partnership with my Costco account, to re-carpet my home and to replace kitchen and foyer flooring. Consultant Jay Carter professionally coordinated a positive and successful outcome. A few minor issues were corrected with no challenge or argument, and the finished results met my expectations. And the total price was very competitive. I have no regrets opting for Smart Carpet & Flooring.
    Terry D.
    Terry D.
    Smart Carpet has great prices, sales/service and installation. Their partnership with Costco is particularly wonderful as you get a rebate in the form of a Costco cash card. When I need carpet, I contact Shayne at Smart Carpet and I’m never disappointed. I highly recommend Smart Carpet.
    Jean G.
    Jean G.
    Jay was great! Took his time to go over many options with us. He left samples so we could take our time and decide as a family what color carpe we wanted.. He was very helpful coordinating tile to the flooring that the tile transitioned to. Installers were great, very professional. Took the time to take apart furniture and carefully move things and put them back in place. We had two sets of stairs, three bedrooms, laundry room and bathroom completed in one day. Such an easy process. Jay has helped several family members of ours in the past and I knew we would have a great experience! He did not disappoint! I highly recommend Jay for all your flooring needs.
    Donna M.
    Donna M.
    Smart Carpet salesman Andrew Egan was very accomodating, friendly, and made choosing my carpet very fast and easy. I love the quality. The installer (Samy) contacted me the day before and came on time. He did an excellent job. I am very pleased with Smart Carpet.
    Joseph H.
    Joseph H.
    Thank you Joe Orlando and Smart Carpet and Flooring for a fantastic install of my cortec vinylflooring in my home. I will recommend them to everyone. Clean,efficient, fast and they cleaned the job site spotless.
    Jackie L.
    Jackie L.
    Just had carpeting installed in two rooms and my staircase at my home in Essex County, NJ. From the beginning of the experience to the end, Smart carpet really delivered. Louie was my sales guy and he walked us through our options at a price in our budget. The two guys that installed my carpet were polite, professional and really hard working. They moved my heavy furniture and the piano and put things back after they were done. Louie came to check on the day of the job. I am a repeat customer (9 years ago they did another carpet install for me). Also, prices are very fair, which is surprising since everything seems to cost more these days. Highly recommend Smart Carpet!
    Peg S.
    Peg S.
    Bob D.has been so interested in helping me with my big decision on carpet for my upstairs. No only did he order me a bigger sample from the company so I could really imagine the right colors. I would text or call him for different questions I had.Additionally, we had a flood in the downstairs and on 9/2 and since I’m in limbo about the installation of the carpet until the remediation team downstairs is done. So I called Bob first to see what to do.Hopefully I will have the new carpet installed soonSincerely,Margaret Sweeney
    Timothy L.
    Timothy L.
    The installer’s work was amazing & admirable. They were fast, clean, quiet, friendly, professional, & resourceful. The carpet is a positive plus within itself. We love the work & satisfied with the SMART Carpet results.
    Kishore A.
    Kishore A.
    We went through Costco for recarpeting the house and had someone from Smart Carpet and Flooring come by for estimates. Bob Dolan visited us and he was very helpful and very patient to answer all the questions we had. He showed us different samples with varied price ranges and walked us through the features of each one of them.
    js_loader

    Awards and Accreditations

    GET A FREE ESTIMATE TODAY

      By submitting this form, I provide my consent to be contacted via text message. I understand that I can revoke this consent at any time.

      Or Call us at