Vinyl Plank Flooring or Wood Tile: How to Decide

Unsure where to start? 

Our Mobile Showrooms

Will Come To You

    By submitting this form, I provide my consent to be contacted via text message. I understand that I can revoke this consent at any time.

    or call us at

    Homeowners wishing to upgrade their flooring have an abundance of options. Among those, two of the most popular are luxury vinyl plank flooring and wood tile. The flooring you choose will have a tremendous impact on how your home looks, feels, and functions.

    SMART Carpet and Flooring specializes in providing the highest quality carpet and flooring services to residential and business customers in New Jersey, Staten Island, and eastern Pennsylvania. Here, we offer insight for customers deciding between vinyl plank flooring and wood tile and what you need to know about both.

    What Is Vinyl Plank Flooring?

    Vinyl plank flooring, also called luxury vinyl plank, is a synthetic material made up of multiple layers. The flooring is presented in long, narrow strips rather than traditional tile squares. Vinyl plank flooring is designed to mimic the look of other, generally more expensive flooring options, such as hardwood, stone, or marble.

    Luxury vinyl plank flooring is constructed with four layers:

    • A top layer of aluminum oxide to protect against light scratching and scuffs from normal wear and tear
    • A clear film layer to protect against severe ripping and tearing
    • A design layer that mimics the look of another type of flooring

    A rigid vinyl backing layer that makes up almost 90% of the total thickness of the flooring

    What Is Wood Tile?

    Wood tile, also known as wood-look tile, is ceramic or porcelain-based tile flooring that is designed to look like wood. The characteristics of wood are printed on top of the tile to provide the illusion of authentic hardwood flooring. Wood tile is available in a wide variety of wood species, grains, colors, and distress levels.

    Comparing the Two Types of Flooring

    Both vinyl plank flooring and wood tile offer property owners a variety of benefits, making them great choices for renovation projects. When considering which option best suits your needs, keep in mind the following:

    Durability

    All flooring options are susceptible to wear and tear over time. However, in terms of durability, vinyl plank flooring and wood tile are two of the most durable flooring products available. With proper upkeep, owners can expect both flooring options to last. Given their strength, durability, and ability to withstand wear and tear, vinyl plank flooring and wood tile are great flooring options for areas of the home that experience heavy foot traffic.

    Maintenance

    Keeping floors pristine requires routine maintenance. Homeowners want a flooring option that looks great without much upkeep. Thankfully, both luxury vinyl plank flooring and wood-look tile require minimal maintenance. Typically, all that’s needed is regular sweeping with a broom and occasional deep cleaning with a mop. However, the grout lines on the wood tile may require additional care.

    Water Resistance

    One of the biggest appeals of vinyl plank flooring and wood tile is their ability to resist water. Traditional wood flooring and water don’t mix well. Therefore, homomers are reluctant to install hardwood in areas of the house where water is common, such as the bathroom, kitchen, and laundry room. Because vinyl plank flooring and tile are completely waterproof, homeowners can have the look of wood in these areas of the home without the worry of water damage.

    Available Styles

    Flooring is a major component of a home or commercial property and a crucial design element. Property owners want to be able to choose from a wide variety of styles, colors, and sizes. Customers will find several options of vinyl plank flooring and wood tile that effortlessly mimic the look of the most popular types of wood and other expensive flooring options. Furthermore, when selecting vinyl plank and wood tile, you can choose from traditional, modern, and rustic looks, allowing you to choose the ideal flooring option for your space.

    Cost

    In many cases, cost is the ultimate deciding factor when choosing new flooring. The price of both vinyl plank and wood tile ranges and is heavily influenced by numerous factors, such as finish, size, and amount. When comparing prices to authentic hardwood, both are affordable alternatives.

    Find Premium Flooring at SMART Carpet and Flooring

    Property owners in New Jersey, Staten Island, and eastern Pennsylvania who are having trouble deciding what flooring options would work best for them should consult SMART Carpet and Flooring. As a locally owned flooring provider, we take great pride in providing flooring services to residential and commercial clients in the communities we serve. Our flooring expertise includes a vast selection of flooring options and professional installation, including vinyl plank and wood tile.

    Clients interested in viewing their options can do so right from their location with our mobile flooring showrooms. Need more carpet or flooring? Shop at home and save when we bring thousands of samples directly to your door.

    We are happy to offer customers free estimates and guarantee transparent, upfront pricing on all our services. For more information about vinyl plank flooring or wood tile, contact us today at SMART Carpet and Flooring.

    SMART Carpet and Flooring
    Excellent
    4.8
    Based on 1114 reviews
    review us on
    Ray S.
    Ray S.
    Jim was very informative, professional and friendly with our purchase! The installers were also professional and friendly. Cleaned up the area very well! Highly recommend Jim and his team at smart carpet!
    Jillian T.
    Jillian T.
    Customer service was great. Installation was so quick and looks absolutely amazing. Matt was awesome! Very knowledgeable and personable. He even came after both of the carpet installations to make sure everything went well and that we were happy.
    Shannon A.
    Shannon A.
    Smooth process from start to finish! Personable in-home consultation and follow-up with our sales manager, Andrew. Quick and efficient installation.
    Pete M.
    Pete M.
    Matt, was great, helped pick out a great style and color of carpet for my home office. Installation was smooth an done quickly, arrived on time they were in and out, and cleaned up great. Would absolutely use Matt and team again.
    Sharon S.
    Sharon S.
    Friendly sales by Ruth Kennedy, Expert installation By Sammy, and professional follow up by Adam Forbes . Would highly recommend to friends and family
    Sheetal P.
    Sheetal P.
    Worked with SmartCarpet as they are the authorized dealers who work with Costco. My estimate was done by John who was great. He reviewed all the options and was professional and through. I did have some issues during my installation but was contacted by SmartCarpet once I gave the feedback. We discussed some areas of improvement and Jude reviewed the process and offered solutions along w/ a direct number for further communication.
    Michele H.
    Michele H.
    Installers were quick, friendly, and cleaned up nicely!
    Joyce K.
    Joyce K.
    Bob was so knowledgeable & helped me pick a great kitchen floor. I just love it!
    Joe S.
    Joe S.
    Smart Carpet and Flooring did an excellent job installing our new carpet in Monroe County! Installation was a clean process and the team handling the service were great and efficient! Our representative Louie was great at walking us through all of our best options and working within our budget. I couldn’t recommend them more!
    Diedra W.
    Diedra W.
    I just had carpet put in all bedrooms. I really love it. The installation guys was very polite and made sure I was satisfied. I would definitely refer Smart Carpet to everyone. Also my representative would came to my home was fantastic.Thanks Bob
    Mary L.
    Mary L.
    Five years ago Smart Carpet put down an engineered floor throughout my new condo, five rooms. It became apparent that the flooring was not holding up well. Smart carpet addressed the issue by replacing parts of the floor. But addition issues kept cropping up. I spoke with John N, my sales rep, who came and examined the floor. He came up with a plan to replace the flooring in my entire condo after five years of use!! He replaced it with a totally new flooring that eliminated all the pitfalls that were associated with the previous product. It has now been six months since my new floor was put down. There are absolutely no issues. The installation is fabulous. I waited this long to write the review so I could see if issues developed. There are none. I couldn’t be happier. The only cost to me was the difference in the cost of the original flooring to the new flooring, minor indeed. The bottom line is that Smart Carpet stands behind their products and their installers. They value their customers!!
    Bet C
    Bet C
    Great service!
    Holli G
    Holli G
    Louie and the carpet installers were fantastic! Really went above and beyond on helping me pick out carpeting and the installers were quick and got the job done! Thank you! From Warren county
    Arif K.
    Arif K.
    Easy initial appointment and at home sales call. No pressure to purchase.Installers arrived on scheduled time and completed the work professionally. Carpet looking great.
    George C.
    George C.
    Ruth was great to deal with, would highly recommend!
    Eve C.
    Eve C.
    What an amazing carpet company! My third floor is a whole new place! I can’t say enough for Andrew and our installation team! Thank you!
    Jack N.
    Jack N.
    Matt did a very professional job. He guided us and gave excellent suggestions. Would highly recommend Matt and Smart Carpet!
    Lynn N.
    Lynn N.
    Bob from Smart carpet was terrific. Explained everything about install. Thanks Bob
    Susan B.
    Susan B.
    Bob Dolan came to my home to measure my for installation as well as show me a range of carpet choices…I found him to be patient and knowledgeable:..he really took his time in helping to educate me about the different qualities without ever making me feel pressured…he was very helpful also in showing me to how to optimize placing seams in the least intrusive location while utilizing the least square footage…I would highly recommend Bob and I would use him again in the future…
    Andrea D.
    Andrea D.
    We had a great experience with Michelle the sales rep, as well as the installation crew. It was an incredibly easy and hassle-free experience for the biggest remodel we ever did!
    Amanda B.
    Amanda B.
    Our new floors were just installed, and we absolutely love them! Price was great and installation went seamlessly! Our salesman Jay was there every step of the way to ensure we were happy! Highly recommend!
    Sanjay P.
    Sanjay P.
    Smart Carpet (Louie, John and Adam )very professional and doing great job. I highly recommends for installation of wood floor with them.
    Haley Y.
    Haley Y.
    I am thrilled that I chose this company to replace the carpet in my basement. Not only was my salesman Louie incredible, but the installer was as well. They both made this process so easy for my family and had my basement looking beautiful. I am located in Sussex county and will contain to use this company for any further installations I may need. 10/10 recommend.
    Sara C.
    Sara C.
    Had the best experience! Steve, our salesman, was so thoughtful and considerate. He spent so much time with us making sure that we were thinking through our options and making the best choices for our space. The installation was incredibly smooth and easy. The installers came on time and worked considerately all day. They cleaned up impeccably and even helped us put some stuff away. I would highly recommend Smart Carpet!
    Kathy G.
    Kathy G.
    From the first meeting for estimate to carpet install day Jim was helpful and easy to work with. The installers did a great job as well. Very happy with the new carpet! Highly recommend
    Lisa S.
    Lisa S.
    Louie was such a nice pleasure to work with. Made it easy and I feel like we were fairly charged. He has great style and helped with my choices. The installers came and did a great job. Very clean installation.
    Gina P.
    Gina P.
    Excellent job cleaned up everything and Louis our sales guy was great and worked with us love my floor. Middlesex County NJ
    Mike L.
    Mike L.
    Matt was great. Very personable and always kept us in the loop throughout the process. He had plenty of options to show us and even helped us find the color that he felt was closest to what we were looking for. Installers were great as well, definitely experienced. I would definitely use them again if I need carpet in another room.
    Donna D.
    Donna D.
    Great service from Michele who came out to measure and go over choices with us to the installers who put the carpet in our bedrooms, etc. Used Smart Carpet in the past and they have excellent customer service no matter how long you’ve had it!
    C P
    C P
    We just had 5 rooms, a hallway and stairs carpeted in our Bergen County home.Our experience with Smart Carpet was wonderful. The sales rep, Louie was professional, prompt and extremely efficient. He took a great deal of time to show us our options and explain the difference between each of them. The installers arrived on time on the scheduled day and worked non stop throughout the day. This included tearing up the old carpet and moving all the furniture which we had emptied previously. We are very pleased with the final product. They are an excellent and professional company to do business with. Thank you Smart Carpet and Flooring.
    Mary A.
    Mary A.
    Ryan was very pleasant and knowledgeable. He showed us a variety of flooring and we found the one we loved. I would highly recommend Smart Carpet and Ryan.
    Amber R.
    Amber R.
    JIM WAS THE MOST AMAZING WORKER OUT THERE! He came right out to help us during a difficult time in our home. The service is OUTSTANDING!!!!!!
    Tubas L.
    Tubas L.
    Work was done on time and the flooring abd carpets were just what we wanted. Otto and the install team were great!!!
    Sarah T.
    Sarah T.
    We recently had beautiful floors installed and could not be happier with the outcome. With 3 dogs and 4 cats, we needed something durable, but also beautiful. Our sales rep, Louie, walked us through the entire process and helped us make an amazing choice. Our new floors gave the entire first floor a face lift. So easy to clean! We were also thrilled that they service the Sussex County area! if I could give 10 stars I would. The financing also made this incredibly affordable for us.
    Tyler S.
    Tyler S.
    Had my bedroom carpeted in all white… it turned out so gorgeous… it was installed by Sam…The salesman that came to the house with samples, Lou, was very nice and knew his stuff… very polite and patient….. it was so nice to shop from home…. I would recommend this business to anyone looking for carpet or flooring…. Lois Steinmann, Northvale, New Jersey
    John S.
    John S.
    Great job, on time and great clean up.
    Jennifer R.
    Jennifer R.
    It was a pleasure working with Shayne and his team!! Shayne Did an awesome job coming out to myhome, measuring the room, and helping me select the perfect carpet. The carpet installers did a great job! Very happy with my new carpeting and I would recommend Smart Carpet and Flooring.
    Rose Mary C.
    Rose Mary C.
    Today, Smart Carpet installed the third carpet in my house. I cannot say enough about this organization. Nicole, the salesperson, was very patient and professional and knew her product well. This is the second time I have had the pleasure of dealing with Nichole. Joe Orlando sold me my first carpet and he was also a professional, pleasant individual. Sam, the installer of the third carpet, was very kind and helpful and made the entire experience stress free. I have recommended Smart Carpet to many friends and I will continue to do so because they are highly reputable. I would highly recommend Smart Carpet and their staff without reservation.
    Linda F.
    Linda F.
    First our saleswoman Ruth Kennedy, was awesome in helping us with our selections. She was courteous, knowledgeable & friendly. Our techs Fabiano & Jose were awesome, fast & professional.Clean up was fantastic. We would highly recommend Smart Carpet to everyone.😊
    Me M.
    Me M.
    Bill Hicks was very patient with me and showed me all my choices. He explained how measurements worked with the way the carpets are made. I did not know the carpet was Shaw until it arrived. It was installed perfectly and efficiently. Jesus was great! I am so happy that I spent the money. It made such a difference in my home. So warm and beautiful.
    shankar R.
    shankar R.
    The experience was smooth. Job done nicely with no issues. Technicians were cooperative and discussed with us for inputs before installing. Cleared up the work area before leaving.
    Daniel M.
    Daniel M.
    I live in Bergen County & had my loft done by Smart Carpet. They offer a free estimate. The salesman, Louie, was top notch and spent over an hour with me going through selections at different prices. He followed up each step of the way. The installers were in and out and did a flawless job. Highly recommend and reasonably price.
    AnnMarie W.
    AnnMarie W.
    Very professional and easy. The cost was reasonable and the job was well done.
    Jon
    Jon
    Stress-free installation from start to finish.
    Mike P.
    Mike P.
    Steve was professional and worked with us to find exactly what we needed Smart carpet is always a first go to
    Tami A.
    Tami A.
    We worked with Louie who helped up pick the perfect carpet for our stairs. Even though it was small job, he took time to go over options and show us different carpets in the convenience of our home. His enthusiasm and attention was exceptional! The installation with Max was so quick and efficient. He arrived on time and was very polite and professional. I Highly recommend them and hope to work with them again in the future.! We are located in Bergen County
    Kelly
    Kelly
    I am very happy with our Carpet and gym rubber mat flooring. Louie is very knowledgeable and has a great eye for what would look good in the space. He's patient as well. The installation process was very good too. We will definitely use Smart Carpet in the future. We are in union county.
    Anna M.
    Anna M.
    Louie and the other members of his team provided excellent advice and suggestions. As a resident of Essex County I will not hesitate to use them for future jobs.
    js_loader

    Awards and Accreditations

    GET A FREE ESTIMATE TODAY

      By submitting this form, I provide my consent to be contacted via text message. I understand that I can revoke this consent at any time.

      Or Call us at